Share Forum - Discuss JSE shares and join the Investor Challenge

This is a little confusing.

1) So this means no tax on dividends in S.A,but I should pay tax on the dividends(and any other profits) in the country I am in?

2)Is it possible to claim back dividend taxes I was already charged with?

I just changed my status to non-resident with SARS.However,My broker account is still a local account,even though I opened it overseas.

3)So I still have to submit everything to SARS and they will know not to tax me on foreign income,correct?

My case is likely to be the same as yours as most DTT's are standard. I will pay normal tax on the sale of shares in SA to SARS and get Credit for this in Portugal. As Portuguese tax is a bit higher, I will pay some tax in Portugal.
Once my shares are held for 3 years, then as a non resident in SA, I will pay no CGT in SA but will pay it in Portugal.

Non residents do not pay dividend tax in SA but are liable to pay it in the country of residency.
So whether you paid here makes little diffs as you would have paid it there.

Orca - I and I am sure a number of other people would be most interested in once you have set yourself up in Portugal as to what the real tax implications really are, whether you do end up paying double tax etc. I am sure that you will also look at the European or even London markets and dabble a bit in shares when resident in Portugal, so I would hope that you will continue to post once you have left these shores

A couple of points on residents/non-residents, dividends and DTA's

1. Any dividend is exempt from South African income tax (normal tax), whether resident or not.
2. Dividends received by a non-resident, would still be subject to a dividends withholding tax.  The following being the notable exceptions
       a) any dividend declared by a foreign company listed on the JSE  (i.e. the dividend is paid from a non-resident to a non-resident).  BHP is an example.
       b) where via a DTA, the dividend withholdings tax has been reduced to below the 15% withholding tax rate.  For example, the DTA with the UK, allows the withholding tax to be reduced to 10%.  Having a quick look at the SA-Portugal DTA, the rate stays at 15%
3. To qualify for the exemption/reduction referred to 2(a) or 2(b) above, one needs to apply for exemption with the withholding agent, typically your stock broker.
4. Note that when your residency status (via either the "ordinarily residence" test or "physical presence test"), changes from resident to not resident, you have a deemed capital gain (at current market value) on any shares held for investment purposes.
5. Thereafter,  any capital gains on the RSA shares are exempt from South African Capital gains tax.  But may, depending on local rules, be subject to tax in any other tax jurisdiction.
6. The effect of DTA, is to clear up source rules (i.e. where taxed), and attempt to eliminate any possible double taxation.  Similar rules, also exist in the RSA income tax act which may assist in ensuring you aren't taxed in two countries.
7.  The general underlying principles that exist with DTA, is that you only get taxed once, and that any withholding tax paid in the other country, could be set off against the tax that you pay in the 1st country.  I.e. should you be resident in Portugal, and receive a dividend from a South African company, any withholding tax withhold in South Africa, may (depending on the provisions of the DTA and the Portuguese tax legislation), be set off against your Portuguese tax liability.
8.  Do not assume that a DTA exists between the two countries.  Check - they are all listed on the SARS website.  Individual provisions can differ between DTA's.
9.  Also do not assume South Africa principles apply in other juridicitions, i.e, dividends may be taxed as ordinary income, and the tax rate be higher than the 15% you effectively pay in SA.
10.  If in doubt, consult a tax expert who deals with DTA's.  Tt might save you money.

Hope all the above makes sense

You have to declare it there and see what happens.
Point 4. When you cease to be a SA resident then all your assets will be deemed as sold at closing price the day before you exit. This will be CGT even if you had not yet held for 3 years. Called Exit Tax.
This is not bad as you now will have a higher Base Cost if you had gains or a loss that can be offset against future gains.
In my case, I will score as my CML made massive gains and I will pay CGT instead of normal tax and I get the R30k exclusion.

I must still get clarity on if a non resident still pays CGT after paying the Exit Tax in SA. Different websites state that you do and some state that you don't. Perhaps some of the websites/blogs are dated.
I will ask SARS when I go sign the exit "permission" forms.

Here is a good read from SARS website.http://www.sars.gov.za/ClientSegments/Individuals/Learn-About-Taxes/Pages/Non-Residents.aspx

Seems like if you are non resident in SA, your CGT is not taxed in SA.

Hi,

its a two fold test.  To be regarded as a SA resident, you need to be either ordinarily resident OR meet the physical presence test.  Meet either one of those tests, then you are a SA resident.  In your case, i'd argue that when you formally immigrate AND move your household, you'd meet the ordinarily resident test (to be a non-resident), then you just need to be outside of the requirements of the physical presence test and you'll be outside the SA resident net.

I just want to be clear.

1-As a non-resident am I still supposed to file my foreign earnings on e-filing along with my stock sales profit together(in the same entry) as voluntary disclosure or ITR12?

2-I am not emigrating.I am just a non-resident.Am I correct in assuming that as a non-resident I do not have to submit anything except change my adress?

3-Is it possible to subtract Forex loss's from any gains.For example,lets say I send some money to S.A from a foreign country,and then the Rand drops even furthur significantly.Could that be seen as a loss?