Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - jonb

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 9
1
Great to see you still on here Patrick and sharing very kindly great views which I've always appreciated!!

I'm terrible at math and certainly run for the hills when I have to do a tax return or crunch some numbers!

What I did weigh up though was something like let's say the lowest cost RA here in SA (sub 1% all-in) goes into a balanced fund which roughly over the past 5 years has given an annual review of around 8% and you get that tax benefit of up to 350K away a year and reduce taxable income by as much

As an example, if you just took the funds and bought VT for example or any world ETF you get around 7% annually over the past 5 years

The positives I guess is that it's your money and you can use it when and where you want/is in USD and that itself appreciated to ZAR (plus its 100% in companies in the strongest economies)

but even if you reduced your taxable income on the highest tax bracket by 100K annually that would be a significant saving. Taking in the ZAR performance over the past 5 years then maybe not so much

Just get so many damn mixed views out in the finance world!

Agree 1000% on the TFSA,  only wish that amount would increase but doubt it



I don't have an RA purely because I think that the tax savings now won't be enough to overcome the lower performance and potentially higher costs of the RA.

Then of course there's the problem that a) you will have to pay income tax on the withdrawals one day, and b) your money is locked until you're at least 55, and you end up with a fairly mediocre product.

A TFSA on the other hand is something I think every single South African should have and should max out all the time, but until they allow 100% offshore RAs I'll keep avoiding them.

I do suspect someone in the top tax bracket who expects to retire in a much lower tax bracket can get some decent value about the tax savings, but my maths said I wasn't one of those.

2
I am lucky enough to have gotten a kick into investing younger in life. Over the past 15 years, single stocks mostly in US tech have done really well for me but as I get older I tend to just build core positions in ETFs (global) with VOO / VT and QQQ being my anchor holdings

I am now back in SA after working in the EU for several years, I have been investigating the RA option with the main objective of SA tax optimization

My question:

I'm already gratefully in a position where I have a global stock/ETF portfolio. Should I rather take the disposable income and continue building that global portfolio with the view to retiring one day and drawing as optimally as possible off of that? this way is not restricted to "having to invest" in SA and can keep building in $

Or

Bite the bullet and open an RA with one of the low-cost options directly (Sygnia being the option for me) and use that disposable income to lower my effective tax payable annually

My somewhat simplistic view is that RA's being Reg 28 compliant places some limitations on holdings which might limit returns and at best you just beat out inflation, on retirement you get some payout Tax but the living annuity is still taxed as income so you kinda paying tax anyways which in my simple mind means that initial benefit is reversed to a certain extent, just later in life!

Appreciate your views!

3
Shares / Shifting ZAR to $
« on: March 24, 2020, 12:49:48 pm »
Just wanted to throw this out here as of right now

If you have funds sitting in ZAR cash and relatively easy opportunity to move these to US $ ( not stocks... YET) just keep in cash

Would you do it?

Phase it 30% 50% all go all in

I know its given that emerging market currencies are taking a pounding now as investors flee to cash, do you guys think this will continue?

4
Shares / TAX Efficient options for cash
« on: January 13, 2020, 02:48:12 pm »
Hi All

Been a while since I have been on here! hope all the OG's are alive and kicking  :TU:

I sold a property earlier last year (perfect timing!) and been sitting with the money in cash / My tax guy just told me though that the interest earned will be taxed 45% along with my standard monthly earnings!

So, in essence, that means if a money market fund was belting it and giving you 8% you only just actually getting over 4%

Hoping for some thoughts on these options


1. Buy another property and live in it (don't own property and am currently renting, not sure if I will always live in SA hence wanting liquid but can always let out)

2. I have already used my 209 and 2020 offshore limit, so get a tax clearance and move this cash offshore and slowly feed into a portfolio based in USD ( this portfolio is around 5 years old and pretty well-diversified)

3. Put in in a Satrix world ETF for easy management (easiest option)

4. Keep in cash! (after tax its like 4% max  :-[


I appreciate any thoughts on this!

5
Shares / Re: Investment Strategies for Nomads
« on: July 04, 2018, 10:43:41 pm »
What an interesting topic ! Been following but been to tied up to comment! As Patrick said, looking forward to getting stuck in when things calm down . I have just done 10 years in EU an US , now back in Cape Town for awhile .. have equities in both EU an US, can offer my own findings here with looking for safe standard income equity  drivers in this space that have worked well in the past 10 years. Really interested in the tax outcomes Andre! I think a few of us are looking to do similar so very interesting to see how it rolls ... will keep posted to this thread


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

6
Shares / Re: TFSA
« on: February 24, 2018, 12:56:57 pm »


[/quote]

Personally not keen on splitting it up. My view is to keep it simple (i.e. Platinum Wealth TFSA Basket :whistle:) and I don't think it gets simpler than a unit trust.

ABSA doesn't allow debit orders with auto invest functionality so you have to log into it every month. CoreShares, Sygnia etc. all allow it but... I dunno.

Unit trust please :D
[/quote]

The platinum basket looks good and EE debit is easy enough

Question on the baskets I have never got on EE, you pay the investment fee and then a basket fee every month right ?

What is TER overall ?

And again I am assuming it’s just for ease as one could buy those stock individually monthly but basket just for convenience right?



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

7
Shares / Re: TFSA
« on: February 24, 2018, 11:41:34 am »


If I was to stick with ETFs I would move it to ABSA. If I was to move to unit trusts it would probably be Allan Gray or maybe Sygnia but I haven't thought it through yet.
[/quote]To add to this, Coronation's Balanced Plus fun doesn't look bad either. Only 20% odd offshore exposure so maybe worth supplementing it with a global fund.
[/quote]

@hamster , so this is actually the discussion I was after!  Originally I thought ETF easy peasy go a little local with prop trax and do a global world etf and sit tight .. but in 3/4 years it’s about flat!

The TFSA unit trusts from Coronation for example are lowish costs and blend some with a stable fund which in past consistently gives 8/9% and something balanced ... might be better off ? The uptick in SA once right now and stronger rand are all elements which could be managed where as ETFs just Take the pain

Maybe it’s better 50/50 ? Like a global world ETF and then a unit trust ?

Was asking you as I always remember having a similar view on TFSA allocation. Wanted to see if your thoughts had changed



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

8
Shares / Re: TFSA
« on: February 23, 2018, 08:38:20 am »
I don't trust their platform. It feels like a very manual system with a "slick" UI ion top of it. Over the last three years I've had numerous issues like my total holdings not adding up, repeated incidents where extra charges are applied when buying ETFs and most recently they completely messed up a corporate action and wrongly credited accounts only to reverse it two months later.

It just feels like something is constantly going wrong. I'll keep my small share portfolio there but since the TFSA has grown to a sizable amount I'd like to move it.

Personal opinion. The developer in me is seeing red :p


I have had similar experiences and share your concern here, interested to hear where you would move the TFSA to ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

9
Shares / TFSA
« on: February 20, 2018, 10:18:36 pm »
Is anyone else not feeling great about TFSA results on the ETF route?

I have the sygnia world ETF and prop trax 10
With a blend of STX ind  ... I have had full allocation since TFSA started

All in thirds

Apart from stxind it’s all been pretty weak especially since the rand has strengthened ( cons of an SA based offshore product! )

I wonder if anyone has had any experience with a managed lowish cost fund under TFSA that they the happy with ?




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

10
Shares / Re: Offshore property investment?
« on: December 31, 2017, 11:09:38 am »
I have had experience with property in The Netherlands

Cant help with the mortgage side as I was living there at the time and got funding from my bank as a resident

However depending where you looking, advisable to see if any restriction or penalty on foreigner purchasing buy to let (the Netherlands wasn't so keen on this although a bit of a grey area ) we used a short-term/Airbnb management service which was a bit easier however at 18% management fee and again very much grey area of Dutch law, some flags raised here.

In my experience tenants have not been so straightforward. Unless you have someone on that side ( Friend, family, agent ) it's near impossible to manage from this side.

Also, have a handyman ready. There are always things needing attention when tenants are in play and this is an extra cost

I ended up exiting as it took a lot of time and energy. Hard also to be close to the politics and economics of another country with regard to rates and general property stability so a little risk there when it comes to market conditions.

For me, I just prefer to take all that energy and resource and invest in an offshore vehicle ( could be a global property ETF ) which gives you similar exposure without ALL the stress

Totally depends on what you need out of this, could be more than just investments so not sure!

11
Shares / Re: CRYPTO JOURNEY
« on: December 28, 2017, 03:32:08 pm »
OK

So I have stood on the sidelines for a few years and as you would imagine in hindsight would want to kick myself. Every single Crypto success story has normally sent that warning bell ringing " If its to good to be true it normally is" I, however, am starting to think that we are in the midst of a financial revolution here and would like to slowly become part of this.

So step one:

Account opened on Luno

Account opened with Bitstamp

Account opened on Poloniex


Plan now is to get some Bitcoin on Lumo and shift some to Bitstamp for a split on the top Coins and then use Poloniex for some of the smaller Altcoins

Linked up with some pretty serious groups online for signal purposes and keen to just give it a bash

Sure a number of you all on here are already deeply involved or at the very least curious.

Is anybody keen to get a group going here to start the journey?

jonb what made you opt for Bitstamp and Poloniex to trade on?


I have some close friends who have been on this for the past 5 years, this was there advice . Bitstamp for the major ones and Poloniex for the Alts

Was actually advised to have openings accounts on a whole lot more with reasoning behind each which I will publish here soon as I get a minute.

I have been charting BTC all morning and looks in my humble opinion to be heading into bearish territory, if so will Take that as an in

Happy thanksgiving keep the thread going here!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

12
Shares / Re: CRYPTO JOURNEY
« on: December 27, 2017, 12:13:15 am »
@Thor / @PlatinumWealth ^

What is Discord? Signed up for so many exchanges and signal groups, not sure I can do one more!

13
Shares / CRYPTO JOURNEY
« on: December 26, 2017, 09:14:24 pm »
OK

So I have stood on the sidelines for a few years and as you would imagine in hindsight would want to kick myself. Every single Crypto success story has normally sent that warning bell ringing " If its to good to be true it normally is" I, however, am starting to think that we are in the midst of a financial revolution here and would like to slowly become part of this.

So step one:

Account opened on Luno

Account opened with Bitstamp

Account opened on Poloniex


Plan now is to get some Bitcoin on Lumo and shift some to Bitstamp for a split on the top Coins and then use Poloniex for some of the smaller Altcoins

Linked up with some pretty serious groups online for signal purposes and keen to just give it a bash

Sure a number of you all on here are already deeply involved or at the very least curious.

Is anybody keen to get a group going here to start the journey?


14
Shares / Re: US shares - for those with EE accounts
« on: July 09, 2017, 12:02:42 pm »
Will be very interested to see how dividends are treated. But must say, looking interesting. Always wanted to own VISA - but lot's of really interesting companies there, others for me would me AMD and Nvidia - but looks like lot's of hours of research in front of me - excellent.

So would be interested to know - what you looking at. And what percentage of SA shares will you be selling to buy US shares? I am thinking 1/4 - 1/3

I went about 90% US vs 10% SA about 5 years ago as I was living in the US/EU at the time

Since recently living back in SA again I have started to ( slowly & cautiously ) grow SA portfolio again as I see what companies are doing here in very few cases and believe in it for future, Overall though... if I compare my own single stock selection's growth of US portfolio vs SA over the past 5 years ( very importantly not including any growth of rand dollar decline as I am based in dollars ) the best I can say is my SA portfolio, while had a few wins overall performed like a spluttering VW Beetle!!!!! on the other hand the US portfolio ( very strongly focused on tech and healthcare stocks ) roared like a Ferrari!!

In saying that, it pays to be aware of the strong run the US has been on , Tech is at extremely high multiples, caution advised ... however well worth the research @Mr_Dividend! 

I have had some amazing growth stories over this time with both Visa & NVIDIA being some of them :TU:


15
Shares / Re: US shares - for those with EE accounts
« on: June 18, 2017, 11:28:12 am »
Bloody hell! 40%?!
I wish people would give proper information rather than just spout a single rubbish number.

Here's the real story:
In the US the first $60k is estate tax free, for the rest the tax rates start at 18% for the first $10k, but to get to the 40% bracket you have to have over a $1mil. There is also a potential loophole if you use a trust: https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/Tax/us-tax-us-estate-and-gift-tax-rules-for-resident-and-nonresident-aliens.pdf

In the UK you're far better off. The first £325 000 is tax free, plus if you transfer to your spouse there's no tax. Then if she leaves it to the kids they can get £650 000 tax free.

But wait there's a better way:
I have an Interactive Brokers account in the US which means nothing. I buy an ETF (VWRD) that's listed on the London Stock exchange which also means nothing. The ETF is domiciled in Ireland, now that means something as the following clipping from virtually any irish domiciled fund prospectus:
Quote
However, any gift or inheritance of Shares will be exempt from Irish gift or inheritance tax once:
1. the Shares are comprised in the gift or inheritance both at the date of the gift or inheritance and at the ‘valuation date’ (as defined for Irish capital acquisitions tax purposes);
2. the person from whom the gift or inheritance is taken is neither domiciled nor ordinarily resident in Ireland at the date of the disposition; and
3. the person taking the gift or inheritance is neither domiciled nor ordinarily resident in Ireland at the date of the gift or inheritance.
So if you don't live in Ireland or leave the shares to someone living in Ireland there is no inheritance tax.

Still not convinced. If you're not holding individual shares but ETFs there's more proof from Irish revenue:
Quote
Units in any collective investment undertaking located in the International Financial Services Centre or in the Shannon Customs-Free Airport Zone are exempt from Capital Acquisitions Tax. The exemption also applies to units in Investment Undertakings which qualify for the new collective funds regime introduced by Section 58, Finance Act 2000.
In Ireland they call those funds UCITS funds. What's the full name for VWRD? Yes it's the Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF. No estate duty. Ireland has done an outstanding job positioning themselves as a destination to invest in.

I normally like justonelap, but that post is dangerous as it would discourage people from taking money offshore, meaning they would have to pay far more CGT one day than if they took their money offshore.

Once again! excellent information!!!!

 :TU:

My portfolio is held in a Netherlands Bank which I am still active on travelling out there a few times a year and having lived there several years

Do you think its needed to do anything to safeguard against this?

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 9